Comments on: The GIMP usability http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/ Dave Neary's view of the world Sun, 11 Dec 2011 14:17:21 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Janne http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/comment-page-1/#comment-352 Janne Wed, 30 Nov -0001 00:00:00 +0000 http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/#comment-352 It is kind of amazing how many complain about the usability of the GIMP. I mean I can't be the only one who thinks GIMP doesn't have major usability problems and is infact really powerful as it is.<p/>Most people complaining about the GIMP UI are the ones that have not bothered to learn how GIMP works and expect it to work exactly like PS or PSP. Since it doesn't copy the PS interface as it is, it must be worse.<p/>How many really know how to use PS without learning to use it's interface? Who can easily figure out that a button in a dialog might change it's text and function when you press the alt/mac/whatever key?<p/>Well maybe it's just me, but I think GIMP has a great UI. It is kind of amazing how many complain about the usability of the GIMP. I mean I can’t be the only one who thinks GIMP doesn’t have major usability problems and is infact really powerful as it is.

Most people complaining about the GIMP UI are the ones that have not bothered to learn how GIMP works and expect it to work exactly like PS or PSP. Since it doesn’t copy the PS interface as it is, it must be worse.

How many really know how to use PS without learning to use it’s interface? Who can easily figure out that a button in a dialog might change it’s text and function when you press the alt/mac/whatever key?

Well maybe it’s just me, but I think GIMP has a great UI.

]]> By: nonnano http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/comment-page-1/#comment-353 nonnano Wed, 30 Nov -0001 00:00:00 +0000 http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/#comment-353 The question about the MDI or whatever interfaces isn't imho really important. The #1 usability problem with Gimp for me is that it doesn't have the functionality that would enable one to effortlessly do things. In short, Gimp developers have settled in for tweaking and polishing instead of going forward and implementing the most crucial modern features.<p/>Until GIMP has got dynamic effect layers with good stacking methods it's really not worth using for any creative work. The present logic of manually going through workflows with layers simply doesn't support "crafting" sort of working with images - which would be greatly more efficient. Working with present system is a constant source of frustration, going back dozens of steps to fix something and getting back to see the results. It's really, really inconvenient.<p/>The worst part is that I'm not even hopeful about the proper usability features (I count them as such because you CAN do everything without them, it just is a horrible experience that drives you instantly back to PS) getting implemented soon... The question about the MDI or whatever interfaces isn’t imho really important. The #1 usability problem with Gimp for me is that it doesn’t have the functionality that would enable one to effortlessly do things. In short, Gimp developers have settled in for tweaking and polishing instead of going forward and implementing the most crucial modern features.

Until GIMP has got dynamic effect layers with good stacking methods it’s really not worth using for any creative work. The present logic of manually going through workflows with layers simply doesn’t support “crafting” sort of working with images – which would be greatly more efficient. Working with present system is a constant source of frustration, going back dozens of steps to fix something and getting back to see the results. It’s really, really inconvenient.

The worst part is that I’m not even hopeful about the proper usability features (I count them as such because you CAN do everything without them, it just is a horrible experience that drives you instantly back to PS) getting implemented soon…

]]> By: Abbas Khan http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/comment-page-1/#comment-354 Abbas Khan Wed, 30 Nov -0001 00:00:00 +0000 http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/#comment-354 I do ALL MY PHOTO EDITING in GIMP, (sorry for the caps), and i really would like to see a change in gui. So it's not only users who don't want to learn to use GIMP that feel the need for UI changes. i never heard of gimpshop but thanks to your post now i can still use GIMP but with a GUI the fits more to my needs, FOSS is all about choice, i await the day the official GIMP has some UI changes that concentrate more on usability. I do ALL MY PHOTO EDITING in GIMP, (sorry for the caps), and i really would like to see a change in gui. So it’s not only users who don’t want to learn to use GIMP that feel the need for UI changes. i never heard of gimpshop but thanks to your post now i can still use GIMP but with a GUI the fits more to my needs, FOSS is all about choice, i await the day the official GIMP has some UI changes that concentrate more on usability.

]]> By: Sven http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/comment-page-1/#comment-355 Sven Wed, 30 Nov -0001 00:00:00 +0000 http://blogs.gnome.org/bolsh/2006/09/18/the-gimp-usability/#comment-355 It's shocking to see how few the people who added comments here, actually know about GIMP development. About the hard work that Pippin is doing to prepare gegl for GIMP into the integration which will finally bring layer effects and more to GIMP. Nor about the plans that we are are developing for the user interface after GIMP 2.4. It seems that I need to blog about this stuff more often.<p/>And I should probably also point out that all this would have happened already if we had more people contributing. A handful of developers can only achieve so much in the spare time that they can afford to invest.<br/> It’s shocking to see how few the people who added comments here, actually know about GIMP development. About the hard work that Pippin is doing to prepare gegl for GIMP into the integration which will finally bring layer effects and more to GIMP. Nor about the plans that we are are developing for the user interface after GIMP 2.4. It seems that I need to blog about this stuff more often.

And I should probably also point out that all this would have happened already if we had more people contributing. A handful of developers can only achieve so much in the spare time that they can afford to invest.

]]>