MySQL Needs Your Help, Now!

7:30 am digital

My boss Monty has issued a call to action. It looks like the European Commission is set to rule on the Sun/Oracle merger, and Oracle has used its clout with its customers to generate a mass-mail campaign. So now it’s time for the Free Software community to do the same.

First, let me again say that I am employed by Monty Program, and so this request is not coming from a wholly disinterested party.

Second, the idea that Oracle should not acquire MySQL without limitations or conditions has been championed by such luminaries as Richard Stallman. While Eben Moglen wrote a missive on behalf of Oracle, his idea that any fork using GPL code has the exact same business opportunities Oracle has is, plainly, absurd. It shows a deep misunderstanding of how MySQL’s dual licensing has worked to build a viable business from Free Software. In short, Stallman “gets it,” Moglen does not.

Third, if Oracle believes the “anyone can fork it” argument, why did they not drop this whole matter months ago, saving themselves millions in revenue, and just fork it themselves? ZDnet published an article a month ago saying, “The longer this takes, the more money Sun is going to lose,” Ellison said at the time, insisting he wouldn’t spin off MySQL. Do I believe Larry Ellison is an astute businessman? You bet I do. So the fact he isn’t prepared to believe his own company’s “anyone can fork it!” mantra tells me something. It should tell you something, too.

Forking code saves the code. It does not save the business. Full stop.

Finally, read Monty’s post and act! Thanks!

9 Responses

  1. URGENT: Action Needed to help save MySQL | Colin Charles Agenda Says:

    [...] Kurt von Finck’s thoughts [...]

  2. Cinqodel Says:

    This is exactly the opposite of what Monty says in his comments on his blog:

    That he’s only interested in saving the code for FOSS sake, _NOT_ the business.

    Hmmmm….

  3. mneptok Says:

    Cinqodel,

    Monty’s motivations are one thing. He discusses those on his blog.

    My reasoning is another. I discuss that here.

    The EU has no interest in preserving the code. It’s not their job. But they do have an interest in promoting a free and healthy marketplace. And that’s why I have raised the issues I have.

  4. Markus Says:

    Instead of yet another fork, just improve an existing community-led DB.

  5. the indian wind along the telegraph lines » Blog Archive » MySQL … Help just to Me Says:

    [...] here to read the rest:  the indian wind along the telegraph lines » Blog Archive » MySQL … By admin | category: Uncategorized | tags: action, cinqodel, colin, exactly-the-opposite, [...]

  6. Safe as Milk » Blog Archive » Save Sun jobs, let Oracle finalise acquisition Says:

    [...] on this, but listened on the sidelines, for a while now. But the blogs I read today from Monty and Mneptok lead me to [...]

  7. Che Kristo Says:

    I have already done exactly the opposite…I’m all for the EU being tough on competition law but this is not a case where they are right. MySQL will be just as safe with Oracle as it was with Sun.

  8. Links 14/12/2009: Oracle Makes Commitment and Gets EU Pass | Boycott Novell Says:

    [...] MySQL Needs Your Help, Now! Second, the idea that Oracle should not acquire MySQL without limitations or conditions has been championed by such luminaries as Richard Stallman. While Eben Moglen wrote a missive on behalf of Oracle, his idea that any fork using GPL code has the exact same business opportunities Oracle has is, plainly, absurd. It shows a deep misunderstanding of how MySQL’s dual licensing has worked to build a viable business from Free Software. In short, Stallman “gets it,” Moglen does not. [...]

  9. Kurt von Finck: MySQL Needs Your Help, Now! | TuxWire : The Linux Blog Says:

    [...] original post here:  Kurt von Finck: MySQL Needs Your Help, Now! Share and [...]