22 responses to “No application for this file type…”

  1. JustAGuy

    How does this work?
    I would say not very well – http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=92497

  2. diegoe

    Inkscape can’t open cdr files.

  3. Killerkiwi

    Suggert you have a look at ubuntu nautilus patchs as gnome-app-install does this already

    Show only applications that handle the given file type


  4. frob

    >Inkscape can’t open cdr files.
    It can

  5. michael schurter

    Sorry I’m no help, but it sounds like an amazing feature to have! I’m a Debian user currently, but if politics prevents an awesome project like this from being available to me… I’ll switch!

    Keep up the good work!

  6. foo

    Ubuntu already does something like this, I don’t know which package it is though. There is also this:


  7. A. Walton

    “JustAGuy Says: ”
    Unrelated to this issue. And we’re always looking for patches, so if you want to provide it…

    “Richard Hughes says:
    Anyone know how I could hook PackageKit into this UI so that it handles some recognised formats?”

    To programmatically set an application as default for a type or extension, see g_app_info_set_as_default_for_type() and g_app_info_set_as_default_for_extension(). To just add an application as supporting the type, g_app_info_add_supports_type(). Pretty simple actually.

  8. A. Walton

    (re-read the post): If you want to put a “Search for applications to install and use for this type” button in that dialog, that will require some Nautilus work, but mostly work on your part (you’d need to have a list of installable applications by supported mime-type database somewhere, which I don’t think any package manager currently supports, though it probably wouldn’t be hard to do inside of your tool, you just need to index .desktop files).

  9. http://users.student.lth.se/f04us/wiki/contact/

    Such “smart features” should be optional. Yeah my head will explode if too much ubuntuism spreads.

    However, one way to solve it here which would be unobtrusive and nice, would be just to add a button “Help me find an application”/”Search for application”/whatever, that takes you to some sort of package kit helper.

  10. Neil J. Patel

    Hi Richard,

    You want to look at nautilus/libnautilus-private/nautilus-mime-actions.c, I believe this dialog is created there.

    – Neil

  11. PackageKit ci suggerirà quali applicazioni installare « pollycoke :)

    […] al lettore più intraprendente). È una semplice deduzione derivante dalla lettura di questo post di Richard Hughes ;) OOXML OpenSolaris Ottimizzare Oxygen PackageKit Parigi Photoshop Plasma Politica […]

  12. Chris Sherlock

    It might be obvious, but is it relying on the extension name? Or will it try to detect the actual type of file?

  13. James Westby

    Hi Richard,

    Is the intention here to have it display a list of applications, and make
    it easy to install them from this dialog, or to just provide a button to pop
    up a further dialog in which to search/install applications?



  14. Victor Bogado

    I would say that this information would have to be integrated with yum. That way it could be updated when new packages could handle different file types and also it would re-use the cache system that already exists.

  15. James Westby

    Hi Richard,

    apt doesn’t have this capability, but Ubuntu ships the information in a separate
    package for the gnome-app-install tool. I’m not sure if mime types are there, but
    they certainly could be.

    The information could obviously be made available through apt as well.



  16. Dan Nicholson

    Hey Richard, I think this script would do the trick:

    for f in `find /usr/share/applications -name ‘*.desktop’`; do
    sed -n ‘s/^ *MimeType=\(.*\)/\1/p’ $f | \
    awk -F';’ ‘{for(i=1;i<=NF;i++) if ($i) printf “mime(%s)\n”, $i}’

    Adjusting the find to operate on $RPM_BUILD_ROOT and supplying the rpm macro magic as needed. Probably you could drop the sed and get it all in awk, but I’m not that talented. If you want any more help with this, I’m pretty keen to rpm and how it handles reqprov.

  17. Ted Gould

    Inkscape does support CDR, but doesn’t update it’s mime types so that it gets listed. :( According to the desktop file we’re SVG only, and that kinda comes from the fact that other things need to be installed to make it work. So if you have Uniconverter and Inkscape, then you can view CDR files. I realize that’s complex, but I’m not sure how you’ll be able to represent that in the provides section of an RPM or DEB.

  18. James Westby


    You could put it in and then use libpackagekit to install uniconverter from inkscape
    if asked to open a CDR file.


  19. tosky

    Please, take a look at this (proposed) freedesktop specification:
    If I remember correctly, KDE implements it.

Bad Behavior has blocked 2769 access attempts in the last 7 days.