Category: Igalia

I’m excited to announce that Epiphany Tech Preview has reached version 3.33.3-33, as computed by git describe. That is 33 commits after 3.33.3:

I’m afraid 3.33.4 will arrive long before we  make it to 3.33.3-333, so this is probably the last cool version number Epiphany will ever have.

I might be guilty of using an empty commit to claim the -33 commit.

I might also apologize for wasting your time with a useless blog post, except this was rather fun. I await the controversy of your choice in the comments.

My previous blog post seems to have resolved most concerns about my requests for Ubuntu stable release updates, but I again received rather a lot of criticism for the choice to make WebKit depend on OpenJPEG, even though my previous post explained clearly why there are are not any good alternatives.

I was surprised to receive a pointer to ffmpeg, which has its own JPEG 2000 decoder that I did not know about. However, we can immediately dismiss this option due to legal problems with depending on ffmpeg. I also received a pointer to a resurrected libjasper, which is interesting, but since libjasper was removed from Ubuntu, its status is not currently better than OpenJPEG.

But there is some good news! I have looked through Ubuntu’s security review of the OpenJPEG code and found some surprising results. Half the reported issues affect the library’s companion tools, not the library itself. And the other half of the issues affect the libmj2 library, a component of OpenJPEG that is not built by Ubuntu and not used by WebKit. So while these are real security issues that raise concerns about the quality of the OpenJPEG codebase, none of them actually affect OpenJPEG as used by WebKit. Yay!

The remaining concern is that huge input sizes might cause problems within the library that we don’t yet know about. We don’t know because OpenJPEG’s fuzzer discards huge images instead of testing them. Ubuntu’s security team thinks there’s a good chance that fixing the fuzzer could uncover currently-unknown multiplication overflow issues, for instance, a class of vulnerability that OpenJPEG has clearly had trouble with in the past. It would be good to see improvement on this front. I don’t think this qualifies as a security vulnerability, but it is certainly a security problem that would facilitate discovering currently-unknown vulnerabilities if fixed.

Still, on the whole, the situation is not anywhere near as bad as I’d thought. Let’s hope OpenJPEG can be included in Ubuntu main sooner rather than later!

I’m very pleased to (belatedly) announce the release of Epiphany 3.32 and WebKitGTK 2.24. This Epiphany release contains far more changes than usual, while WebKitGTK continues to improve steadily as well. There are a lot of new features to discuss, so let’s dive in.

Dazzling New Address Bar

The most noticeable change is the new address bar, based on libdazzle’s DzlSuggestionEntry. Christian put a lot of effort into designing this search bar to work for both Builder and Epiphany, and Jan-Michael helped integrate it into Epiphany. The result is much nicer than we had before:

The address bar is a central component of the user interface, and this clean design is important to provide a quality user experience. It should also leave a much better first impression than we had before.

Redesigned Tabs Menu

Epiphany 3.24 first added a tab menu at the end of the tab bar. This isn’t very useful if you have only a few tabs open, but if you have a huge number of tabs then it’s useful to help navigate through them. Previously, this menu only showed the page titles of the tabs. For 3.32, Adrien has converted this menu to a nice popover, including favicons, volume indicators, and close buttons. These enhancements were primarily aimed at making the browser easier to use on mobile devices, where there is no tab bar, but they’re nice improvement for desktop users, too.

(On mobile, the tab rows are much larger, to make touch selection easier.)

Touchpad Gestures

Epiphany now supports touchpad gestures. Jan-Michael first added a three-finger swipe to Epiphany, for navigating back and forward. Then Alexander (Exalm) decided to go and rewrite it, pushing the implementation down into WebKit to share as much code as possible with Safari. The end result is a two-finger swipe. This was much more involved than I expected as it required converting a bunch of Apple-specific Objective C++ code into cross-platform C++, but the end result was worth the effort:

Applications that depend on WebKitGTK 2.24 may opt-in to these gestures using webkit_settings_set_enable_back_forward_navigation_gestures().

Alexander also added pinch zoom.

Variable Fonts

Carlos Garcia decided to devote some attention to WebKit’s FreeType font backend, and the result speaks for itself:

Emoji 🦇

WebKit’s FreeType backend has supported emoji for some time, but there were a couple problems:

• Most emoji combinations were not supported, so while characters like🧟(zombie) would work just fine, characters like 🧟‍♂️(man zombie) and 🧟‍♀️(woman zombie) were broken. Carlos fixed this. (Technically, only emoji combinations using a certain character code were broken, but that was most of them.)
• There was no code to prefer emoji fonts for rendering emoji, meaning emoji would almost always be displayed in non-ideal fonts, usually DejaVu, resulting in a black and white glyph rather than color. Carlos fixed this, too. This seems to work properly in Firefox on some websites but not others, and it’s currently WONTFIXed in Chrome. It’s good to see WebKit ahead of the game, for once. Note that you’ll see color on this page regardless of your browser, because WordPress replaces the emoji characters with images, but I believe only WebKit can handle the characters themselves. You can test your browser here.

Improved Adaptive Mode

First introduced in 3.30, Adrien has continued to improve adaptive mode to ensure Epiphany works well on mobile devices. 3.32 is the first release to depend on libhandy. Adrien has converted various portions of the UI to use libhandy widgets.

Reader Mode

Jan-Michael’s reader mode has been available since 3.30, but new to 3.32 are many style improvements and new preferences to choose between dark and light theme, and between sans and serif font, thanks to Adrian (who is, confusingly, not Adrien). The default, sans on light background, still looks the best to me, but if you like serif fonts or dark backgrounds, now you can have them.

JPEG 2000

Wait, JPEG 2000? The obscure image standard not supported by Chrome or Firefox? Why would we add support for this? Simple: websites are using it. A certain piece of popular server-side software is serving JPEG 2000 images in place of normal JPEGs and even in place of PNG images to browsers with Safari-style user agents. (The software in question doesn’t even bother to change the file extensions. We’ve found far too many images in the wild ending in .png that are actually JPEG 2000.) Since this software is used on a fairly large number of websites, and our user agent is too fragile to change, we decided to support JPEG 2000 in order to make these websites work properly. So Carlos has implemented JPEG 2000 support, using the OpenJPEG library.

This isn’t a happy event for the web, because WebKit is only as secure as its least-secure dependency, and adding new obscure image formats is not a step in the right direction. But in this case,  it is necessary.

Mouse Gestures

Experimental mouse gesture support is now available, thanks to Jan-Michael, if you’re willing to use the command line to enable it:

$ gsettings set org.gnome.Epiphany.web:/org/gnome/epiphany/web/ enable-mouse-gestures true

With this, I find myself closing tabs by dragging the mouse down and then to the right. Down and back up will reload the tab. Straight to the left is Back, straight to the right is Forward. Straight down will open a new tab. I had originally hoped to use the right mouse button for this, as in Opera, but turns out there is a difference in context menu behavior: whereas Windows apps normally pop up the context menu on button release, GTK apps open the menu on button press. That means the context menu would appear at the start of every mouse gesture. And that is certainly no good, so we’ve opted to use the middle mouse button instead. We aren’t sure whether this is a good state of things, and need your feedback to decide where to go with this feature.

Improved Fullscreen Mode

A cool side benefit of using libdazzle is that the header bar is now available in fullscreen mode by pressing the mouse towards the top of the screen. There’s even a nice animation to show the header bar sliding up to the top of the screen, so you know it’s there (animation disabled for fullscreen video).

The New Tab Button

Some users were disconcerted that the new tab button would jump from the end of the tab bar (when multiple tabs are open) back up to the end of the header bar (when there is only one tab open). Now this button will remain in one place: the header bar. Since it will no longer appear in the tab bar, Jan-Michael has moved it back to the start of the header bar, where it was from 3.12 through 3.22, rather than the end. This is mostly arbitrary, but makes for a somewhat more balanced layout.

The history of the new tab button is rather fun: when the new tab button was first added in 3.8, it was added at the end of the header bar, but moved to the start in 3.12 to be more consistent with gedit, then moved back to the end in 3.24 to reduce the distance it would need to move to reach the tab bar. So we’ve come full circle here, twice. Only time will tell if this nomadic button will finally be able to stay put.

New Icon

Yes, most GNOME applications have a new icon in 3.32, so Epiphany is not special here. But I just can’t resist the urge to show it off. Thanks, Jakub!

And More…

It’s impossible to mention all the improvements in 3.32 in a single blog post, but I want to squeeze a few more in.

Alexander (Exalm) landed several improvements to Epiphany’s theme, especially the incognito mode theme, which needed work to look good with the new Adwaita in 3.32.

Jan-Michael added an animation for completed downloads, so we don’t need to annoyingly pop open the download popover anymore to let you know that your download has completed.

Carlos Garcia added support for automation mode. This means Epiphany can now be used for running automated tests with WebDriver (e.g. with Selenium). Using the new automation mode, I’ve upstreamed support for running tests with Epiphany to the Web Platform Tests (WPT) project, the test suite used by web engine developers to test standards conformance.

Carlos also reworked the implementation of script dialogs so that they are now modal only to their associated web view, not modal to the entire application. This means you can just close the browser tab if a particular website is abusing script dialogs in a problematic way, e.g. by continuously opening new dialogs.

Patrick has improved the directory layout Epiphany uses to store data on disk to avoid storing non-configuration data under ~/.config, and reworked the internals of the password manager to mitigate Spectre-related concerns. He also implemented Happy Eyeballs support in GLib, so Epiphany will now fall back to an IPv4 connection if IPv6 is available but broken.

Now Contains 100% Less Punctuation!

Did you notice any + signs missing in this blog? Following GTK+’s rename to GTK, WebKitGTK+ has been renamed to WebKitGTK. You’re welcome.

Whither Pop!_OS?

Extra Credit

Although Epiphany 3.32 has been the work of many developers, as you’ve seen, I want to give special credit Epiphany’s newest maintainer, Jan-Michael. He has closed a considerable number of bugs, landed too many improvements to mention here, and has been a tremendous help. Thank you!

Now, onward to 3.34!

Jan-Michael has recently changed Epiphany Technology Preview to use a separate app ID. Instead of org.gnome.Epiphany, it will now be org.gnome.Epiphany.Devel, to avoid clashing with your system version of Epiphany. You can now have separate desktop icons for both system Epiphany and Epiphany Technology Preview at the same time.

Because flatpak doesn’t provide any way to rename an app ID, this means it’s the end of the road for previous installations of Epiphany Technology Preview. Manual intervention is required to upgrade. Fortunately, this is a one-time hurdle, and it is not hard:

$ flatpak uninstall org.gnome.Epiphany

Uninstall the old Epiphany…

$ flatpak install gnome-apps-nightly org.gnome.Epiphany.Devel org.gnome.Epiphany.Devel.Debug

…install the new one, assuming that your remote is named gnome-apps-nightly (the name used locally may differ), and that you also want to install debuginfo to make it possible to debug it…

$ mv ~/.var/app/org.gnome.Epiphany ~/.var/app/org.gnome.Epiphany.Devel

…and move your personal data from the old app to the new one.

Then don’t forget to make it your default web browser under System Settings -> Details -> Default Applications. Thanks for testing Epiphany Technology Preview!

WebKit currently has four network backends:

• CoreFoundation (used by macOS and iOS, and thus Safari)
• CFNet (used by iTunes on Windows… I think only iTunes?)
• cURL (used by most Windows applications, also PlayStation)
• libsoup (used by WebKitGTK+ and WPE WebKit)

One guess which of those we’re going to be talking about in this post. Yeah, of course, libsoup! If you’re not familiar with libsoup, it’s the GNOME HTTP library. Why is it called libsoup? Because before it was an HTTP library, it was a SOAP library. And apparently somebody thought that when Mexican people say “soap,” it often sounds like “soup,” and also thought that this was somehow both funny and a good basis for naming a software library. You can’t make this stuff up.

Anyway, libsoup is built on top of GIO’s sockets APIs. Did you know that GIO has Object wrappers for BSD sockets? Well it does. If you fancy lower-level APIs, create a GSocket and have a field day with it. Want something a bit more convenient? Use GSocketClient to create a GSocketConnection connected to a GNetworkAddress. Pretty straightforward. Everything parallels normal BSD sockets, but the API is nice and modern and GObject, and that’s really all there is to know about it. So when you point WebKitGTK+ at an HTTP address, libsoup is using those APIs behind the scenes to handle connection establishment. (We’re glossing over details like “actually implementing HTTP” here. Trust me, libsoup does that too.)

Things get more fun when you want to load an HTTPS address, since we have to add TLS to the picture, and we can’t have TLS code in GIO or GLib due to this little thing called “copyright law.” See, there are basically three major libraries used to implement TLS on Linux, and they all have problems:

• OpenSSL is by far the most popular, but it’s, hm, shall we say technically non-spectacular. There are forks, but the forks have problems too (ask me about BoringSSL!), so forget about them. The copyright problem here is that the OpenSSL license is incompatible with the GPL. (Boring details: Red Hat waves away this problem by declaring OpenSSL a system library qualifying for the GPL’s system library exception. Debian has declared the opposite, so Red Hat’s choice doesn’t gain you anything if you care about Debian users. The OpenSSL developers are trying to relicense to the Apache license to fix this, but this process is taking forever, and the Apache license is still incompatible with GPLv2, so this would make it impossible to use GPLv2+ software except under the terms of GPLv3+. Yada yada details.) So if you are writing a library that needs to be used by GPL applications, like say GLib or libsoup or WebKit, then it would behoove you to not use OpenSSL.
• GnuTLS is my favorite from a technical standpoint. Its license is LGPLv2+, which is unproblematic everywhere, but some of its dependencies are licensed LGPLv3+, and that’s uncomfortable for many embedded systems vendors, since LGPLv3+ contains some provisions that make it difficult to deny you your freedom to modify the LGPLv3+ software. So if you rely on embedded systems vendors to fund the development of your library, like say libsoup or WebKit, then you’re really going to want to avoid GnuTLS.
• NSS is used by Firefox. I don’t know as much about it, because it’s not as popular. I get the impression that it’s more designed for the needs of Firefox than as a Linux system library, but it’s available, and it works, and it has no license problems.

So naturally GLib uses NSS to avoid the license issues of OpenSSL and GnuTLS, right?

Haha no, it uses a dynamically-loadable extension point system to allow you to pick your choice of OpenSSL or GnuTLS! (Support for NSS was started but never finished.) This is OK because embedded systems vendors don’t use GPL applications and have no problems with OpenSSL, while desktop Linux users don’t produce tivoized embedded systems and have no problems with LGPLv3. So if you’re using desktop Linux and point WebKitGTK+ at an HTTPS address, then GLib is going to load a GIO extension point called glib-networking, which implements all of GIO’s TLS APIs — notably GTlsConnection and GTlsCertificate — using GnuTLS. But if you’re building an embedded system, you simply don’t build or install glib-networking, and instead build a different GIO extension point called glib-openssl, and libsoup will create GTlsConnection and GTlsCertificate objects based on OpenSSL instead. Nice! And if you’re Centricular and you’re building GStreamer for Windows, you can use yet another GIO extension point, glib-schannel, for your native Windows TLS goodness, all hidden behind GTlsConnection so that GStreamer (or whatever application you’re writing) doesn’t have to know about SChannel or OpenSSL or GnuTLS or any of that sad complexity.

Now you know why the TLS extension point system exists in GIO. Software licenses! And you should not be surprised to learn that direct use of any of these crypto libraries is banned in libsoup and WebKit: we have to cater to both embedded system developers and to GPL-licensed applications. All TLS library use is hidden behind the GTlsConnection API, which is really quite nice to use because it inherits from GIOStream. You ask for a TLS connection, have it handed to you, and then read and write to it without having to deal with any of the crypto details.

As a recap, the layering here is: WebKit -> libsoup -> GIO (GLib) -> glib-networking (or glib-openssl or glib-schannel).

So when Epiphany fails to load a webpage, and you’re looking at a TLS-related error, glib-networking is probably to blame. If it’s an HTTP-related error, the fault most likely lies in libsoup. Same for any other GNOME applications that are having connectivity troubles: they all use the same network stack. And there you have it!

P.S. The glib-openssl maintainers are helping merge glib-openssl into glib-networking, such that glib-networking will offer a choice of GnuTLS or OpenSSL and obsoleting glib-openssl. This is still a work in progress. glib-schannel will be next!

P.S.S. libcurl also gives you multiple choices of TLS backend, but makes you choose which at build time, whereas with GIO extension points it’s actually possible to choose at runtime from the selection of installed extension points. The libcurl approach is fine in theory, but creates some weird problems, e.g. different backends with different bugs are used on different distributions. On Fedora, it used to use NSS, but now uses OpenSSL, which is fine for Fedora, but would be a license problem elsewhere. Debian actually builds several different backends and gives you a choice, unlike everywhere else. I digress.

Last month, I attended the Web Engines Hackfest (hosted by Igalia in A Coruña, Spain) and also the WebKit Contributors Meeting (hosted by Apple in San Jose, California). These are easily the two biggest WebKit development events of the year, and it’s always amazing to meet everyone in person yet again. A Coruña is an amazing city, and every browser developer ought to visit at least once. And the Contributors Meeting is a no-brainer event for WebKit developers.

One of the main discussion points this year was Media Source Extensions (MSE). MSE is basically a way for browsers to control how videos are downloaded. Until recently, if you were to play a YouTube video in Epiphany, you’d notice that the video loads way faster than it does in other browsers. This is because WebKitGTK+ — until recently — had no support for MSE. In other browsers, YouTube uses MSE to limit the speed at which video is downloaded, in order to reduce wasted bandwidth in case you stop watching the video before it ends. But with WebKitGTK+, MSE was not available, so videos would load as quickly as possible. MSE also makes it harder for browsers to offer the ability to download the videos; you’ll notice that neither Firefox nor Chrome offer to download the videos in their context menus, a feature that’s been available in Epiphany for as long as I remember.

So that sounds like it’s good to not have MSE. Well, the downside is that YouTube requires it in order to receive HD videos, to avoid that wasted bandwidth and to make it harder for users to download HD videos. And so WebKitGTK+ users have been limited to 720p video with H.264 and 480p video with WebM, where other browsers had access to 1080p and 1440p video. I’d been stuck with 480p video on Fedora for so long, I’d forgotten that internet video could look good.

Unfortunately, WebKitGTK+ was quite late to implement MSE. All other major browsers turned it on several years ago, but WebKitGTK+ dawdled. There was some code to support MSE, but it didn’t really work, and was disabled. And so it came to pass that, in September of this year, YouTube began to require MSE to access any WebM video, and we had a crisis. We don’t normally enable major new features in stable releases, but this was an exceptional situation and users would not be well-served by delaying until the next release cycle. So within a couple weeks, we were able to release WebKitGTK+ 2.22.2 and Epiphany 3.30.1 (both on September 21), and GStreamer 1.14.4 (on October 2, thanks to Tim-Philipp Müller for expediting that release). Collectively, these releases enabled basic video playback with MSE for users of GNOME 3.30. And if you still use of GNOME 3.28, worry not: you are still supported and can get MSE if you update to Epiphany 3.28.5 and also have the aforementioned versions of WebKitGTK+ and GStreamer.

MSE in WebKitGTK+ 2.22.2 had many rough edges because it was a mad rush to get the feature into a minimally-viable state, but those issues have been polished off in 2.22.3, which we released earlier this week on October 29. Be sure you have WebKitGTK+ 2.22.3, plus GStreamer 1.14.4, for a good experience on YouTube. Unfortunately we can’t provide support for older software versions anymore: if you don’t have GStreamer 1.14.4, then you’ll need to configure WebKitGTK+ with -DENABLE_MEDIA_SOURCE=OFF at build time and suffer from lack of MSE.

Epiphany 3.28.1 uses WebKitSettings to turn on the “enable-mediasource” setting. Turn that on if your application wants MSE now (if it’s a web browser, it certainly does). This setting will be enabled by default in WebKitGTK+ 2.24. Huge thanks to the talented developers who made this feature possible! Enjoy your 1080p and 1440p video.

When building WebKitGTK+, it’s a good idea to stick to the default values for the build options. If you’re building some sort of embedded system and really know what you’re doing, then OK, it might make sense to change some settings and disable some stuff. But Linux distros are generally well-advised to stick to the defaults to avoid creating problems for users.

One exception is if you need to disable certain features to avoid newer dependencies when building WebKit for older systems. For example, Ubuntu 18.04 disables web fonts (ENABLE_WOFF2=OFF) because it doesn’t have the libbrotli and libwoff2 dependencies that are required for that feature to work, hence some webpages will display using subpar fonts. And distributions shipping older versions of GStreamer will need to disable the ENABLE_MEDIA_SOURCE option (which is missing from the below feature list by mistake), since that requires the very latest GStreamer to work.

Other exceptions are the ENABLE_GTKDOC and ENABLE_MINIBROWSER settings, which distros do want. ENABLE_GTKDOC is disabled by default because it’s slow to build, and ENABLE_MINIBROWSER because, well, actually I don’t know why, you always want that one and it’s just annoying to find it’s not built.

OK, but really now, other than those exceptions, you should probably leave the defaults alone.

The feature list that prints when building WebKitGTK+ looks like this:

--  ENABLE_ACCELERATED_2D_CANVAS .......... OFF
--  ENABLE_DRAG_SUPPORT                     ON
--  ENABLE_GEOLOCATION .................... ON
--  ENABLE_GLES2                            OFF
--  ENABLE_GTKDOC ......................... OFF
--  ENABLE_ICONDATABASE                     ON
--  ENABLE_INTROSPECTION .................. ON
--  ENABLE_JIT                              ON
--  ENABLE_MINIBROWSER .................... OFF
--  ENABLE_OPENGL                           ON
--  ENABLE_PLUGIN_PROCESS_GTK2 ............ ON
--  ENABLE_QUARTZ_TARGET                    OFF
--  ENABLE_SAMPLING_PROFILER .............. ON
--  ENABLE_SPELLCHECK                       ON
--  ENABLE_TOUCH_EVENTS ................... ON
--  ENABLE_VIDEO                            ON
--  ENABLE_WAYLAND_TARGET ................. ON
--  ENABLE_WEBDRIVER                        ON
--  ENABLE_WEB_AUDIO ...................... ON
--  ENABLE_WEB_CRYPTO                       ON
--  ENABLE_X11_TARGET ..................... ON
--  USE_LIBHYPHEN                           ON
--  USE_LIBNOTIFY ......................... ON
--  USE_LIBSECRET                           ON
--  USE_SYSTEM_MALLOC ..................... OFF
--  USE_WOFF2                               ON

And, asides from the exceptions noted above, those are probably the options you want to ship with.

Why are some things disabled by default? ENABLE_ACCELERATED_2D_CANVAS is OFF by default because it is experimental (i.e. not great :) and requires CairoGL, which has been available in most distributions for about half a decade now, but still hasn’t reached Debian yet, because the Debian developers know that the Cairo developers consider CarioGL experimental (i.e. not great!). Many of our developers use Debian, and we’re not keen on having two separate sets of canvas bugs depending on whether you’re using Debian or not, so best keep this off for now. ENABLE_GLES2 switches you from desktop GL to GLES, which is maybe needed for embedded systems with crap proprietary graphics drivers, but certainly not what you want when building for a general-purpose distribution with mesa. Then ENABLE_QUARTZ_TARGET is for building on macOS, not for Linux. And then we come to USE_SYSTEM_MALLOC.

USE_SYSTEM_MALLOC disables WebKit’s bmalloc memory allocator (“fast malloc”) in favor of glibc malloc. bmalloc is performance-optimized for macOS, and I’m uncertain how its performance compares to glibc malloc on Linux. Doesn’t matter really, because bmalloc contains important heap security features that will be disabled if you switch to glibc malloc, and that’s all you need to know to decide which one to use. If you disable bmalloc, you lose the Gigacage, isolated heaps, heap subspaces, etc. I don’t pretend to understand how any of those things work, so I’ll just refer you to this explanation by Sam Brown, who sounds like he knows what he’s talking about. The point is that, if an attacker has found a memory vulnerability in WebKit, these heap security features make it much harder to exploit and take control of users’ computers, and you don’t want them turned off.

USE_SYSTEM_MALLOC is currently enabled (bad!) in openSUSE and SUSE Linux Enterprise 15, presumably because when the Gigacage was originally introduced, it crashed immediately for users who set address space (virtual memory allocation) limits. Gigacage works by allocating a huge address space to reduce the chances that an attacker can find pointers within that space, similar to ASLR, so limiting the size of the address space prevents Gigacage from working. At first we thought it made more sense to crash than to allow a security feature to silently fail, but we got a bunch of complaints from users who use ulimit to limit the address space used by processes, and also from users who disable overcommit (which is required for Gigacage to allocate ludicrous amounts of address space), and so nowadays we just silently disable Gigacage instead if enough address space for it cannot be allocated. So hopefully there’s no longer any reason to disable this important security feature at build time! Distributions should be building with the default USE_SYSTEM_MALLOC=OFF.

The openSUSE CMake line currently looks like this:

%cmake \
  -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Release \
  -DLIBEXEC_INSTALL_DIR=%{_libexecdir}/libwebkit2gtk%{_wk2sover} \
  -DPORT=GTK \
%if 0%{?suse_version} == 1315
  -DCMAKE_C_COMPILER=gcc-7 \
  -DCMAKE_CXX_COMPILER=g++-7 \
  -DENABLE_WEB_CRYPTO=OFF \
  -DUSE_GSTREAMER_GL=false \
%endif
%if 0%{?suse_version} <= 1500
  -DUSE_WOFF2=false \
%endif
  -DENABLE_MINIBROWSER=ON \
%if %{with python3}
  -DPYTHON_EXECUTABLE=%{_bindir}/python3 \
%endif
%if !0%{?is_opensuse}
  -DENABLE_PLUGIN_PROCESS_GTK2=OFF \
%endif
%ifarch armv6hl ppc ppc64 ppc64le riscv64 s390 s390x
  -DENABLE_JIT=OFF \
%endif
  -DUSE_SYSTEM_MALLOC=ON \
  -DCMAKE_EXE_LINKER_FLAGS="-Wl,--as-needed -Wl,-z,now -pthread" \
  -DCMAKE_MODULE_LINKER_FLAGS="-Wl,--as-needed -Wl,-z,now -pthread" \
  -DCMAKE_SHARED_LINKER_FLAGS="-Wl,--as-needed -Wl,-z,now -pthread"

which all looks pretty reasonable to me: certain features that require “newer” dependencies are disabled on the old distros, and NPAPI plugins are not supported in the enterprise distro, and JIT doesn’t work on odd architectures. I would remove the ENABLE_JIT=OFF lines only because WebKit’s build system should be smart enough nowadays to disable it automatically to save you the trouble of thinking about which architectures the JIT works on. And I would also remove the -DUSE_SYSTEM_MALLOC=ON line to ensure users are properly protected.

Here’s a little timeline of some fun we had with the GNOME master Flatpak runtime last week:

• Tuesday, July 10: a bad runtime build is published.  Trying to start any application results in error while loading shared libraries: libdw.so.1: cannot open shared object file: No such file or directory. Problem is the library is present in org.gnome.Sdk instead of org.gnome.Platform, where it is required.
• Thursday, July 12:  the bug is reported on WebKit Bugzilla (since it broke Epiphany Technology Preview)
• Saturday, July 14: having returned from GUADEC, I notice the bug report and bisect the issue to a particular runtime build. Mathieu Bridon fixes the issue in the freedesktop SDK and opens a merge request.
• Monday, July 16: Mathieu’s fix is committed. We now have to wait until Tuesday for the next build.
• Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday: we deal with various runtime build failures. Each day, we get a new build log and try to fix whatever build failure is reported. Then, we wait until the next day and see what the next failure is. (I’m not aware of any way to build the runtime locally. No doubt it’s possible somehow, but there are no instructions for doing so.)
• Friday, July 20: we wait. The build has succeeded and the log indicates the build has been published, but it’s not yet available via flatpak update
• Saturday, July 21: the successful build is now available. The problem is fixed.

As far as I know, it was not possible to run any nightly applications during this two week period, except developer applications like Builder that depend on org.gnome.Sdk instead of the normal org.gnome.Platform. If you used Epiphany Technology Preview and wanted a functioning web browser, you had to run arcane commands to revert to the last good runtime version.

This multi-week response time is fairly typical for us. We need to improve our workflow somehow. It would be nice to be able to immediately revert to the last good build once a problem has been identified, for instance.

Meanwhile, even when the runtime is working fine, some apps have been broken for months without anyone noticing or caring. Perhaps it’s time for a rethink on how we handle nightly apps. It seems likely that only a few apps, like Builder and Epiphany, are actually being regularly used. The release team has some hazy future plans to take over responsibility for the nightly apps (but we have to take over the runtimes first, since those are more important), and we’ll need to somehow avoid these issues when we do so. Having some form of notifications for failed builds would be a good first step.

P.S. To avoid any possible misunderstandings: the client-side Flatpak technology itself is very good. It’s only the server-side infrastructure that is problematic here. Clearly we have a lot to fix, but it won’t require any changes in Flatpak.

If you use Epiphany Technology Preview, please update immediately and ensure you have revision 3.29.2-26 or newer. We discovered and resolved a vulnerability that allowed websites to access internal Epiphany features and thereby exfiltrate passwords from the password manager. We apologize for this oversight.

The unstable Epiphany 3.29.2 release is the only affected release. Epiphany 3.29.1 is not affected. Stable releases, including Epiphany 3.28, are also not affected.

There is no reason to believe that the issue was discovered or exploited by any attackers, but you might wish to change your passwords if you are concerned.