GNOME 3.34 is now managed using systemd

If you are already using GNOME 3.34, then most likely your session is managed using systemd right now. For a long time now we were already running a systemd instance for every user, which is used to launch DBus and for DBus activated applications. So, with GNOME 3.34, we finally took the next step and moved the rest of the session over to run using systemd.

From a user’s perspective nothing should have changed and at this point I believe that most regressions have been dealt with. Neither will this change affect application developers for the time being as XDG autostart files continue to be supported and are prefered at least for the time being.

The great thing is, that this enables further improvements. There has been a lot of work to allow Xwayland to be started on demand and systemd plays a small part in that feature. Similar, we will also be able to shut down services that are only needed if specific hardware is present (e.g. smartcards). Also, using systemd it is now easy to sandbox all components which will give you an extra bit of security.

That said, there are a few changes, concepts and general information that is worth mentioning.

Slices, scopes and user sessions

On a systemd managed system each user is assigned a user-X.slice (systemd.slice(5)) and the user’s session will be run in a session-Y.scope (systemd.scope(5)). You can also see a few other user specific units on the host, including user@X.service, which is the user’s systemd instance. This is a separate systemd process for the user and it will shut down again if the user is not logged in anymore.

With the systemd move, not only DBus activated applications and services, but rather your entire session is now launched using your user’s systemd instance. This has a few side effects that may seem odd at first. For example, the previously mentioned session-Y.scope which used to contain over 200 processes is now down to a mere 4 processes. Another side effect is that it got harder to understand which session a process belongs to (this is relevant for a number of services) or that ps will not show a tty anymore.

But, we have addressed these side effects and hopefully there are no regressions at this point. Your GNOME session is still invariably bound to the session-Y.scope (e.g. using loginctl kill-session continues to work reliably). And services have been updated to understand the new regime and pick the correct session in all cases. To handle all this, new API was also added to the systemd DBus interface and further improvements may happen in this area.

Trying it out

So, if you have GNOME 3.34, you can now apply all the neat tools that systemd has manage your user’s session. Just remember to add the --user option, and things should work as expected. A good candidate for trying all this out is gsd-media-keys.

If we look at systemctl --user, we’ll find two entries:

  • gsd-media-keys.service

Note that failed units will not show up in the list, so it is advisable to always check the log if you suspect a service failure. Unfortunately this is needed so that you can reliably log in again after a session failure.

We can control (not gsd-media-keys.service), so you can try stopping and starting it and you will notice that most global keybindings will stop and start working.

  • systemctl --user stop
  • systemctl --user start

We can also pull up the log messages for the service from journalctl.

  • journalctl --user -u gsd-media-keys.service

But, unfortunately, it will not log much information by default. But, knowing systemd and GLib environment variables we can run:

  • systemctl --user --runtime edit gsd-media-keys.service

and write:

  • [Service]

This enables debug messages when the service is restarted next. The configuration will not persist as we passed --runtime. If you now restart and inspect its log again, you will notice that it contains a lot more information.

Developing GNOME

If you have a development version of GNOME installed somewhere outside of your normal path (e.g. jhbuild) and use this to log in, then you may need to update your setup. In jhbuild there is an example jhbuild-session script that ensures that the correct unit files will be used. The relevant lines copy them into the user’s $XDG_RUNTIME_DIRECTORY and reload the systemd daemon.

On a final note, I would like to thank everyone who has worked on this in the past. As far as I know, the first experimentations were done by Canonical, in particular Iain Lane did a lot of work and submitted the first patches. I picked up this work and made plenty of improvements to get it over the finishing line.

If you don’t have GNOME 3.34 yet, then try it out by installing Fedora 31 beta or your favourite distribution that includes GNOME 3.34 already.

21 thoughts on “GNOME 3.34 is now managed using systemd”

    1. Yep, you can do this. Have a look at how gnome-settings-daemon already does it. It boils down to adding X-GNOME-HiddenUnderSystemd=true to the XDG autostart file and then providing your own systemd service.

      That said, please don’t consider the target names used in GNOME to be stable at this point. Tracker should be fine as it can be updated in sync with GNOME if a change happens. But that will not be the case for other projects.

      If you want to be on the safe side, then it probably is better to go through DBus activation though.

  1. Very nice work!
    Running GNOME 3.34 under Debian sid here. I didn’t even notice the switch until you blogged about it.

    One regression I noticed is, that applications started via XDG autostart start too early, before the shell (and in my case the kstatusnotifier extension) is loaded. The result is, that those applications are not shown in the systray. It seems X-GNOME-Autostart-Phase=Application is not really having an effect anymore.

    For the time being, I start the nextcloud client via a shell script and put a sleep 10 before I exec the binary. I obviously want to get rid of this hack.

    Do you consider the above a bug in gnome-session and should I file a corresponding bug report?

    1. It is true that applications start earlier currently. The effect currently means that XDG autostart applications may launch before the gnome-settings-daemon processes have been fully loaded. In most cases, including this case, that should make no difference though.

      What I suspect happened in your case is that the gnome-settings-daemon startup was simply always “slow” enough for the shell to have loaded the relevant extension already. This is something that may have worked but has always been fragile. Applications should probably notice it when the kshellnotifier extension is loaded later on.

      That said, technically there is a bug here. We should only start launching the XDG autostart files in the Application phase after the session is fully initialized. We already have one such synchronization point and we can add another one easily. Please file a bug about this against gnome-session and we can address this. However, as said above, it may not fix the issue you are seeing.

  2. My man, congratulations to you and Iain on this fabulous work. It’s been a long time coming and I’m glad we’ve finally got rid of gnome-session.

    One thing that I’m interested in is the ability to assign cgroups to specific applications. Things like web browsers frequently will eat CPU and of course on a laptop that eats battery. Would we be able to apply default cgroups for general launching of applications and maybe a specific groups of apps? I queried this elsewhere, and initially people thought it was not possible, but Lennart said it was. So I’m hoping it is something that we can have in scope.

    1. gnome-session actually still exists. There are still tasks it does and it is also needed for XDG autostart files (that part might change).

      These changes do not affect launching of normal applications. Most of them are already launched using DBus activation anyway and in some cases that means that a systemd service is started (e.g. gnome-terminal). One can probably restrict applications a bit that way, but I suspect that Flatpak might provide a more fitting infrastructure to do these kind of things.

    2. To “assign cgroup to specific applications”, those applications should run as separate systemd –user units. The most obvious way is to start them as units, as e.g. various gnome services described in this article are. But other ways are possible, for example using scopes or systemd-run.

      Once a process is running as a separate systemd unit, normal resource control mechanisms supported by systemd apply. There’s a gotcha here: for unprivileged units, like all systemd –user units, cgroups v2 hierarchy is required (which actually is now the default in Fedora 31).

      For example:

      $ systemctl --user cat memcheck.service
      # /home/zbyszek/.config/systemd/user/memcheck.service
      ExecStart=sleep infinity

      $ tail /sys/fs/cgroup/user.slice/user-1000.slice/user@1000.service/memcheck.service/memory.{high,low,max}
      ==> /sys/fs/cgroup/user.slice/user-1000.slice/user@1000.service/memcheck.service/memory.high /sys/fs/cgroup/user.slice/user-1000.slice/user@1000.service/memcheck.service/memory.low /sys/fs/cgroup/user.slice/user-1000.slice/user@1000.service/memcheck.service/memory.max <==

  3. I’ve been pushing for similar changes in KDE/Plasma, it’s been a slow boring process splitting some of the core startup things, but we’re getting there too.

    I have some questions, maybe this isn’t the best forum, but you can direct me where to go.
    (I’ve also made absolutely no effort to just read your code)

    How do you handle knowing which desktop you’re loading and act accordingly? Are any parts built with a generator? How are third party .desktop files in autostart dirs handled?

    For a recent project, we experimented with an idea to make launching /all apps/ a systemd unit. We replaced the “start menu” code with a path that created transient units effectively calling (“systemd-run –user –scope –unit someDesktopFileName someExe”)

    It allowed for some useful UI grouping of running processes, and eventually applying better resource management at runtime (as firefox is too many processes normally) is that a direction gnome could also be interested in?

    1. How do you handle knowing which desktop you’re loading and act accordingly?/quote>

      We are using a template unit for this. So gnome-session launches gnome-session-{x11,wayland} which then pulls in everything else.

      Are any parts built with a generator? How are third party .desktop files in autostart dirs handled?

      Right now we are still using the old code for all of this and almost nothing has changed for these applications. The idea of using a generator has been floating around, but unfortunately we would need a separate daemon for this to work. This is because we have a feature where the autostart application is started if a certain configuration key is active. Something that simply cannot be mapped to any Condition rule in systemd.

      For a recent project, we experimented with an idea to make launching /all apps/ a systemd unit. We replaced the “start menu” code with a path that created transient units effectively calling (“systemd-run –user –scope –unit someDesktopFileName someExe”)

      I would love to see these kind of changes. For any dbus activated application something similar is already happening in many cases. But we are not doing this otherwise, which is actually creating a few issues currently.

      In that regard, I am wondering if we should set BindTo for such units to guarantee that they are killed at log out.

      1. Thanks for the replies.

        >I would love to see these kind of changes.

        Where would be a good place to follow that last point up?

        P.S ski 2020?

  4. I am running Debian sid, and I think I upgraded the system yesterday. This morning, the mouse and the keyboard would be frozen in the gdm3 login screen. There probably was only the background image and a mouse pointer on the screen. The mouse pointer would move for maybe the first half a second and then freeze.

    The whole system was not frozen; I was able to log in via sshd. I temporarily resolved the problem by downgrading gdm3 from 3.34 to 3.30. (Actually, I did not get a gdm3 screen at all, maybe because I did not downgrade all needed packages, but I was able to invoke “startx” from the text-based virtual console.)

    I did not notice anything obvious in the logs.

    Maybe the issue will be resolved in a few days when more packages are updated. I thought that it would be good to mention this, in case someone else runs in to the same issue.

    1. There is one way that I can imagine that such an issue is related. It is a bit of a long shot, but logind/mutter may have gotten confused about which session is active. This would point to a version mismatch though, so it could be a good idea to first check that you are on 3.34 for all components (gnome-shell, mutter, gdm and maybe more).

      If it happens again, you could check whether the corresponding session is shown as active using loginctl. Also, maybe try switching VTs using chvt or loginctl activate.

      That said, it may also well be that this is completely unrelated to these changes.

      1. I did not have time to debug it yesterday, and the problem was magically fixed today (after installing some updates yesterday). I think that all packages were on 3.34 already yesterday morning. Today morning’s update included gnome-session 3.34.0-3 and some others. Before updating today, I did get a gdm3 screen, but when logging in, I would get the “something was wrong” popup screen.

        1. Aha! I think this might have been caused by an issue in gnome-initial-setup that we fixed a while ago. Good to hear this has been resolved for you.

  5. Aha, this must be why software such as Aruba VIA (a crufty QT program) are now no longer obeying theme settings when I first log in, and must be restarted to pick up my dark theme.

    And maybe why own cloud and Nextcloud no longer reliably show up in the app indicator area (why these two have not adopted libcloudproviders yet is an endless source of frustration to me).

    1. Yeah, that sounds like the issue I described more in reply to Michael earlier. We are not synchronizing application auto-starting with some processes right now, which explains the dark theme issue at least.

      The right thing to do with this is to open a bug against gnome-session. It should not be hard to deal with. But, as said before, it is unlikely to guarantee a fix for all cases.

  6. One of your tips can cause gpg to break. To explain:

    I ran the settings for adding G_MESSAGES_DEBUG=all to gsd-media-keys :
    systemctl –user –runtime edit gsd-media-keys.service

    and it broke gpg-agent. Why?

    Because I launch my terminals with hotkeys, they inherit the environment from gsd-media-keys. When I use something requiring a gpg key (git, gpg, etc.) a gpg-agent is launched with G_MESSAGES_DEBUG=all environment variable. When gpg-agent launches pinentry-gtk-2 or pineentry-gnome3 they both break because the G_MESSAGES_DEBUG causes pinentry-gtk/gnome3 logging to stdout which is where the communications occurs between pinentry and gpg-agent.

    a fix for me was to put “unset G_MESSAGES_DEBUG” in my .bashrc. This took my a while to figure out what was happening and why this happened, so I figured I would report this here.

  7. So what about the other OSes like the BSDs and other non-systemd systems that run GNOME? Just to hell with them?

    1. The old startup mechanism is still used for legacy applications and is fully functional. It has been in maintenance mode for a long time. Should we start using generators in the future (this is unlikely to happen very soon though), then this code would become obsolete on systems where systemd is available.

      So yeah, in the long run that might increase the burden on the non-systemd ecosystem slightly as they may need to provide patches should things break. Other than that, I expect that the still working code will simply continue to exist indefinitely.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *