ODF vs OOX : Asking the wrong questions

Recent posts from Brian Jones (Microsoft) and Robert Weir (IBM) highlight the strange times we live in. A squadron of flying pigs are out doing loops. On one hand you have MS documenting their file format, and providing positive press for competitors. On the other you’ve got IBM paying full time staff to critique development versions of Gnumeric. I’d like to thank both authors for their publicity, and triaging, but I also want to point out that IMO their examples are looking at things the wrong way.

Brian’s example of Numbers reading an OOX file written by Gnumeric could just as easily been an XLS file. Indeed that would likely have had better support on both ends.   The binary format was poorly documented and a miserable pain to read, but it’s been around a long time as is the dominant interchange format. All spreadsheets needed to support it.

Rob heads off in another direction with his examination of Gnumeric’s limited support for xlsx, on both import and export. What he neglects to consider is the amount of effort required. The initial importer was written on the flight to London for the ECMA meeting, and export was added on the flight back. Toss in a few hours of debugging and the sample file produced by Brian’s example was under a week of effort to read and write. After reading his post I added basic chart import and export the following day.Basic XLSX chart import

This was several orders of magnitude simpler than writing the binary filters which required parsers for OLE2, BIFF, and binary expressions just to get far enough to start reading the format details. However, even that is not the most salient question to ask. The core of this argument is the OOX vs ODF showdown. Instead what implementers really want to know is :

How hard was it to implement ODF support compared to OOX ?

it was significantly more difficult. To be clear, ODF support was nowhere near as much work as the old binary filters, we are talking about XML here. However, while Import filters start with parsing the structure, in the end, extracting the basic state is no more than the ante for the real work. You need to handle the impedance mismatches between the concepts in the file format, and your implementation. ODF’s model of ‘chartness’ didn’t fit well with Gnumeric. In contrast XLSX may be ugly, but it”s concepts were very familiar from XLS. We already had much of the code required to handle it.

I suspect most spreadsheet implementers are in the same position.

Out of a rut and onto the trading floor

May was my last month with Novell, and the OpenOffice.org project. Working with Michael, and the rest of the Ximian/Novell team, since my son was born 6 years ago has been great. It doesn’t get much better than earning a living writing free software. However, while taking an unplanned hike through the Czech country side, discussing spreadsheet data-structures (isn’t that what everyone does while hiking?), Gnumeric came up, and I remembered how it felt ‘back in the day’. An important part of open source development had slipped away without my realizing it. This is supposed to be FUN!

OO.o is an important project for the free software cause, but after 2 years, I was still 1-2 orders of magnitude more productive in Gnumeric. Spelunking can be interesting, but it wears thin after a while, and when something isn’t fun, it becomes work. When an old colleague from the investment world called with a job offer, I accepted. It was time for change.

  • Time to leave my basement (at least for a while) and commute into downtown.
  • Time to play with C#, ASP.NET and some nifty toys (you can make almost windows feel like Linux now)
  • Time to eat sushi and decent Thai food on the patio of BCE place.
  • Time to sit on the trading floor and interact with live people, with the latest financial news (eg Paris Hilton leaving prison stay)
  • I’m even contemplating making the jump from vim to emacs (only very briefly, vim7 drew me back)

Change is billowing through my daily routine, and with a clear separation of work and fun my Gnumeric time is back.

Posted in General, Gnumeric, OpenOffice.org. Comments Off on Out of a rut and onto the trading floor

Joining OO.o too

I’ve been quiet for too long now. It’s time to say hi, re-join the
community, and do a bit of spreadsheet blogging.

For the last few months I’ve been working on OOo’s spreadsheet. Given the
choice between working on OOo and leaving free software I swallowed my pride
and made the leap.

To paraphrase the late Douglas Adams

‘OOo, is big. Really big. You just won’t believe how vastly
hugely mindbogglingly big it is. I mean you may think there’s a lot of code
in emacs, but that’s just peanuts compared to OOo.”

There’s lot’s of neat stuff in here, and Michael has done some amazing work
getting it building mostly painlessly.

Gnumeric is still alive and well. The team is on track to release 1.6.0 (with
several nice improvements) along with gnome 2.12 in a few weeks. With luck
I’ll be able to cross-pollinate the projects.

My current project in OOo is to add support for R1C1 style references. The
core of the patch was simple. I was able to lift a blob of Gnumeric code I’d
written a few months back and dual license for inclusion in OOo. The tricky
bit is turning out to be the interface change that propagates the choice of
address style.

Posted in Gnumeric, OpenOffice.org. Comments Off on Joining OO.o too

Where we stand

libgoffice
The vacation gave me a bit of time to bite the bullet and start working on pulling this out of gnumeric in earnest. Both kids got sick, and the resulting sleepless exhaustion limited development time, but at least the end
is in sight. The remaining elements are

  • Expand GOFont to include sttributes likes strike/underline/color
  • Finish the font selector widget to use the attributes
  • Pull down the date convention code (needed for value formatting)
  • Move the heart of the value formatter down
  • Move the format selector down
  • Get the last of the GOPlugin code in place
  • Move the plugin manager dialog down

That’s still lots of work but it should be possible within 1-2 weekends.

Gnumeric
I had tidied up escher export a few weeks ago to enable chart export to xls. Jon Kare picked that up and has been working on image export, something people have been asking for for a long time. Sitting in my inbox was also some absolutely lovely work by Emmanuel to complete his work axis mapping (invert, log) for the 1.5d charts (col/bar/line/area). While he was at it he ripped out all the piecewise patching for libart antialiasing fuzziness, and consolidated it into the pixbuf renderer. The results look awesome.
Couple in Kasal’s recent gsf-janitor work to polish up the msole exporter and we’re looking good for a release. There are still a few win32 porting patches to merge in, but on the whole we should be able to release gnumeric with
gnomeoffice-1.2 in conjunction with gnome-2.8.

Posted in Gnumeric, libgsf. Comments Off on Where we stand

Sax & Web

Not sleeping well so I spent a few hours doing some mindless coding to complete the sax-style xml exporter for gnumeric. I’ll make it the default for 1.3.1 to get some testing. There’s a huge speed win for large files. Not allocating 4*uncompressed size is apparently helpful.

Had an intereting chat with Ryan, Charlie, and Mark to marvel at the existence and virtues of Trelane’s work on the new Gnumeric website. It can certainly be polished in spots, but the architecture is clean, and it’s a hell of a lot better than the monkey see monkey do crud I’ve be putting up. It is fantastic to finally have some web knowledgeable folk available to put up some more polished a more polished gnome-office website.

Posted in Gnumeric. Comments Off on Sax & Web