Squib of the day: same button, different position

Red colorful buttonsGNOME bug 120705 points out that Metacity doesn’t allow users to put a button into the titlebar twice– so, for example, you can’t have a close button on the left and also on the right hand side.

There is no particular reason for this: it was merely an artifact of the original code which has been preserved.  However, not allowing a button to repeat has a possibly useful side-effect of providing an upper bound on the number of buttons which can appear.

Is there anyone out there who would actually want to put a button on the titlebar more than once?

Photo © Kup Kup Land, cc-by-nc-sa.

Published by

Thomas Thurman

Mostly themes, triaging, and patch review.

3 thoughts on “Squib of the day: same button, different position”

  1. Considering changing the button layout isn’t very obvious to begin with unless you live inside of gconf, I don’t see why not to allow it unless it is a colossal code change. If people want to completely obliterate their titlebar usability, why stop them?
    Though, I certainly hope distributors wouldn’t abuse it.

    It seems simpler to just say “type the buttons you want on your titlebar” than to say the same with an additional “you can only use each button once.”

  2. If someone wants to provide a patch, I don’t see any reason to reject it. But it otherwise doesn’t seem like a valuable use of a developer’s time.

  3. Strange as it sounds, I wouldn’t mind this feature, for two reasons:

    1) This would make it easier for me to experiment. Say, put minimize to the left, but keep it in its orthodox position as well, and see if I can get used to the new position.

    2) It would minimize mouse movement: whichever direction I am moving the mouse, I can minimize/close the previously active window.

    Mind you, I won’t spend any time writing code for this margin of usability improvement and I certainly don’t expect anyone else to do it :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported.